File :-(, x, )
Anonymous
Current dream starting 8 in baseball... Strictly defense/No pitcher/any three OF's

2. Brian McCann
3. Mark Texiera
4. Dustin Pedroia
5. ARod
6. Derek Jeter
7. Justin Upton
8. Torri Hunter
9. Josh Hamilton
>> Anonymous
1. Randy Moss
2. Brian McCann
3. Mark Texiera
4. Dustin Pedroia
5. ARod
6. Derek Jeter
7. Justin Upton
8. Torri Hunter
9. Josh Hamilton

Fix'd.
>> Anonymous
ones left off cause its the pitchers position
>> Anonymous
Sage for fat people.
>> Anonymous
>6. Derek Jeter

You already fail HARD. Anyone who takes Jeter over Hanley Ramírez should be locked up in Arkham Asylum.
>> Anonymous
C - AJ Pierzynski
1B - Mark Teixeira
2B - Ian Kinsler
SS - Alexei Ramirez
3B - Alex Rodriguez
LF - Josh Hamilton
CF - Ichiro
RF - Sammy Sosa
>> Anonymous
how many gold gloves/championships does H.R. have compared to DJ? you fail
>> Anonymous
1. Randy Moss
1. Randy Moss
1. Randy Moss
1. Randy Moss
1. Randy Moss
1. Randy Moss
1. Randy Moss
1. Randy Moss
>> Anonymous
hes too busy with nascar
>> Anonymous
>>303152
lol'd
>> Anonymous
>>303142

>You already fail HARD. Anyone who takes Hanley over Jimmy Rollins should be locked up in Arkham Asylum.

Fixed
>> Anonymous
>>303149
Have you seem Jeter play SS in the last couple of years? Or do you have it on mute so you don't here "Past a diving Jeter" 4 or 5 times a game.

And A-Rod's defense at 3rd is average at best.

Mark Texiera, Youkilis right now has a better glove. Also Denard Span and Sizemore are WAY better than Upton and Hamilton.
>> Anonymous
I forgot about Jimmy Rollins.... shit... maybe its cause hes a Philly i hate them and there fans....but then again so does he...there may be something there
>> Anonymous
1-9. Dan Uggla
>> Anonymous
Just defense?

KAY.

P - Kenny Rogers
C - Brian McCann
1B - Mark Teixeira
2B - Alexei Ramirez
SS - Hanley Ramirez
3B - Akinori Iwamura
LF - Torii Hunter
CF - Garret Anderson
RF - Denard Span
>> Anonymous
Jeters defense (even in the gold glove years) is always been bad. He actually costs teams games with with his glove, hes so bad. To even consider him is an insult.

Also, any defensive list with out Nick Punto is a troll
>> Anonymous
3. Doug Fuckin Mientkiewicz
>> Anonymous
No Punto? I guess no one knows about him because he's not a big name.
>> Anonymous
     File :-(, x)
is it sad that Junior is still 1000 times better then Manny at defense and hes twice his age and has had 97 injuries?
>> Anonymous
OP here. Sorry guys I put no thought into the list, I just out down a bunch of famous and well known players.
>> Anonymous
>>303171
For my money he's the most exciting defensive infielder playing right now, but I'm a Twins fan.

Scott Rolen can also do some things.
>> Anonymous
>>303176
Alexei Ramirez. That guy shows up on the top 10 way more than anyone's share.
>> Anonymous
>303176 here

It's also kind of hard to put Punto on the list since he kind of plays all over the IF.
>> Anonymous
who is torris hunter replacement in Minn?
>> Anonymous
Punto/MacDonald
>> Anonymous
>>303182
Gomez, but Span is better.
>> Anonymous
>>303173
No because Ken Griffey was supposed to be the best baseball player ever before he got fucked up from injuries. Manny was never really supposed to be that amazing.
>> Anonymous
>>303182
Carlos Gomez, part of the Johan Santana deal. I've seen him make really good plays and miss a couple of close plays (that I assume Torii would've made). Not sure about his fielding pct or anything, strictly my observations.
>> Anonymous
if Kinsler is not at 2B this list is fail
>> Anonymous
no love for david wright? granted he does play the same position as alex rodriguez
>> Anonymous
>>303258
.........
>> Anonymous
>>303260
nevermind his 13 errors
>> Anonymous
As far a defense:

C-Yadier Molina

1b- Mark Teixeira

2b-Brandon Phillips

SS- Jose Reyes

3b- David Wright

Lf Josh Hamilton

CF- Carlos Beltran

RF- Ryan Church (when healthy, cannon of an arm and can hit)
>> Anonymous
C: Kurt Suzuki
3B: David Wright
SS:Hanley Ramirez
2B:Chase Utley
1B:Albert Pujols
OF:Matt Holliday
OF:Vladimir Guerrero
OF:Curtis Granderson

As for who I'd want on the mound, Carlos Zambrano, Jake Peavy, or Chien-Ming Wang
>> Anonymous
Anyone see David Wright's sick throw to get Victorino tonight?
>> Anonymous
>>303323
Just saw it on sportscenter.
>> Anonymous
>>303324

I was watching it live, here was my train of thought:

-oh shit nice pick put it in your pocket
-WHAT ARE YOU DOING THROWING IT FROM THERE
(throw is going over the middle of the diamond
-HE'S GONNA THROW IT AWAY. THAT FAGGOT.
(ball lands right in Delgado's glove)
-Holy shit Wright! Fuck yeah.
>> Kilgamayan !2BklmILFiE
Defense only, huh?

C: Ivan Rodriguez (close between him and Yadier Molina)
1B: Kevin Youkilis
2B: Alexei Ramirez
SS: John McDonald
3B: Uhh...Adrian Beltre, I guess, though I'd rather take Scott Rolen assuming 100% health. Where'd Eric Chavez go?
LF: Torii Hunter
CF: Grady Sizemore
RF: Ichiro Suzuki
>> Anonymous
Jimmy Rollins is easily the best defensive SS in the game right now, how do you fucks ignore that?
>> Anonymous
>>303323
God damn right he did that. Fuck you Shane Victorino.

And yes, I'm a Mets fan. No I don't hate the Phillies... but fuck do I HATE Shane Victorino.
>> Anonymous
     File :-(, x)
>>303330
>> Anonymous
>>303330

Omar Vizquel says hi.

Jose Reyes ain't no slouch, either.
>> Anonymous
>>303333
>>303335

VIZQUELMIND
>> Anonymous
>>303332

Metsfag here. I'm almost in the same boat as you. I don't really hate the Phillies players. I respect them for showing up and battling. I have an unhealthy amount of hatred for Victorino, though.

Victorino is a "scrappy" piece of shit player just like David Eckstein. So that's probably where the hatred stems from.
>> Anonymous
C - Brian McCann
1B - Mark Texiera
2B - Orlando Hudson
3B - David Wright
SS? - Nick Punto (could've gone in all fields)
OF - Endy Chavez
OF - Torri Hunter
OF - Ichiro
>> Anonymous
>>303357

props to Anonymous for recognizing Endy Chavez's defensive prowess.
>> Anonymous
>>303360
Now only if he had an arm...
>> Anonymous
>>303361

True. True. Endy knows how to patrol the OF, but he has a barely above average arm.
>> Anonymous
How has Todd Helton not been mentioned?

How has Jim Edmonds not be mentioned?
>> Anonymous
     File :-(, x)
>>303335

Oh, hi.

Vizquel is old and Reyes is overrated defensively.
>> Anonymous
>>303376

Because they are both washed up, and Edmonds was never that great to begin with, just flashy.
>> Anonymous
>>303330

One John McDonald would like a word with you.

Sure he sucks at everything else, but the man is a defensive machine
>> Anonymous
>>303385
I am also a Tulowitski fan, but I'd rather have Ramirez
>> Kilgamayan !2BklmILFiE
>>303330

Watch more Blue Jays games.

>>303376

Sizemore has just as good a glove as Edmonds while having better range. Helton, however, is arguably getting snubbed, though I think at this point in their careers, Pujols is sabermetrically the better defender.