File :-(, x, )
Anonymous
Name your top 3 NFL quarterbacks

1. Montana
2. Staubach
3. Marino
>> Anonymous
in before Rax Grissman
>> Anonymous
1. rax grissman
2. rax grissman
3. rax grissman
>> Anonymous
1. Troy Aikman
2. Quincy Carter
3. Tony Romo
>> Anonymous
>>299060
faggot
>> Anonymous
> 1. Randy Moss
> 1. Randy Moss
> 1. Randy Moss
>> Anonymous
>>299060
i lol'd
>> Sneak !!+y8MDiWrdyT
     File :-(, x)
1. BRETT FAVRE
2. BRETT FAVRE
3. BRETT FAVRE

AND JUST BECAUSE BRETT FAVRE

4. BRETT FAVRE
>> Anonymous
Elway
P Manning
Montana
>> Anonymous
Montana, Favre, Brady.
>> Black ? Star !x8ngkAZjXE
go with the ones I seen growing up. Unitas and bradshaw I could watch all day though.

1. Brady
2. Steve Young
3. Manning
>> Anonymous
     File :-(, x)
>>299060
only number 3. come on!
>> Anonymous
>>299067
underage b&/
>> Anonymous
1.Brady
2.Montana
3.Unitas
>> PhilKenSebben !qNgkjhpu0A
1. Marino
2. Elway
3. Hasselbeck
>> Anonymous
1. Unitas
2. Montana
3. Brady
>> Anonymous
>>299083
correct answer
>> Anonymous
>>299083
second.
>> Anonymous
Brady is an average QB with sound mechanics on a good team. Fuck anyone with him on a list.

Brady isn't even the best of his generation. Peyton Manning is better.
>> Anonymous
>>299091
You sure?

I'm a Boltsfag, and Brady is the best current QB right now by far. He's easily Top 5 all-time.
>> Anonymous
1) Jim Plunkett
2) Brett Favre
3) Peyton Manning
>> Anonymous
>>299091
sound mechanics
amazing pocket presence
terrific team leader
beautiful timing and aim
>> Anonymous
>>299094
I repeat: Manning is better.

Brady isn't horrible. In fact, he's quite good. But he isn't as good as Manning, and would not be capable of leading shitty teams to wins like other great QB's.
>> Anonymous
>>299101
mannings team is pretty shitty right now, so well see.

also the 2001 patriots werent all that good
>> Anonymous
>>299098

>amazing pocket presence

did you watch this last superbowl? cracks under any pressure. his pocket presence = he stands in one spot as his fucking amazing offensive line does work.
>> Anonymous
>>299098
He's great statistically, but he doesn't do anything special. He doesn't take the entire offense into his own hands, he hasn't led any historic drives that will be remembered for years to come, not to mention one of his achievements was a downright gift. Top 10 QBs of all time? Definitely. Top 3? Fuck off.
>> Sup /cle/ Anonymous
     File :-(, x)
1. Bernie Kosar
2. Otto Graham
3. Brian Sipe
>> Anonymous
>>299101
Yes, because the rest of that '01 offense was amazing, and he had a lot of weapons to work with when he brought them a minute away from the Super Bowl in '07.

I'll give you that he had a good defense helping him in '01 but he still won them a Super Bowl with Troy Brown as his best receiver and Antowain Smith as the running back.
>> Anonymous
other than that one game. that rush was fantastic. watch any other games he steps away from the rush really well
>> Anonymous
>>299114
He does, but as I said, he's not top 3. I think everyone here is just absorbed with the present.

Mabye when he has legendary drives/plays, or completely takes over an important game over all odds, I'll consider it. Until then: Nope.
>> Anonymous
>>299107
>he hasn't led any historic drives that will be remembered for years to come

Besides the first two Super Bowls he won, right?
>> Anonymous
1. Unitas
2. Montana
3. P. Manning
>> Anonymous
>>299125
No one but Patriot fans remember that. Don't bring that garbage in here. It's nowhere near the same recognition as THE DRIVE or THE CATCH.
>> Anonymous
>>299124
by those standards manning is no where close to top 3
>> MIGHTY MIGHTY BOSTON !3GqYIJ3Obs
1. Tom Brady

2. John Baskett

3. Ken Gilnett
>> MIGHTY MIGHTY BOSTON !3GqYIJ3Obs
>>299133

My /b/ I meant

Kevin Gilnett
>> Anonymous
>>299133
dont even bother /sp/.

mega troll
>> Anonymous
>>299131
He controls his entire offense, so he's still better.

But you're right. He's not top 3 material yet.
>> Anonymous
where is todd hudson on mighty bostons list?
>> Anonymous
>>299138
>eftroll
>> Anonymous
1. Montana
2. Dan Marino
3. Dan Fouts
>> Anonymous
>>299146
That's better. Though I'd replace Fouts with Elway.
>> MIGHTY MIGHTY BOSTON !3GqYIJ3Obs
>>299138

>mega troll

Your thinking of your mom.
>> Anonymous
     File :-(, x)
>Brady isn't horrible. In fact, he's quite good. But he isn't as good as Manning, and would not be capable of leading shitty teams to wins like other great QB's.

I'm sorry but that's one of the dumbest quotes I've read here. The AFC championship game came down to the last few minutes while he had scrubs like Reche Caldwell receiving for him. And then Caldwell actually pretty much ended up losing the game for them by dropping a pass he was begging for with his creepy eyes. I then lol'd
>> Anonymous
>>299157
That was far from a shitty team. Marino had shitty teams. You know nothing of shitty teams.
>> Anonymous
>>299157
And Manning has people like Harrison to throw to.

I fucking hate the bastard, but Brady is a fantastic quarterback when he's healthy.
>> Anonymous
1. Marino
2. Jay Fiedler
3. Cleo Lemon
>> Anonymous
>>299166
Fantastic isn't the issue. The issue is that Pats fans can't even reason why Brady would be better than Steve Young, let alone top 3 of all time.
>> tom
1. randy moss
>> Anonymous
>>299149
Elway had so many clutch comebacks it's hard to deny.
But, it was fun watching Coryell chargers picking apart defenses.
>> Anonymous
     File :-(, x)
1. QB Eagles
2. QB Bills
3. QB Browns
>> caperus
1 brett favre
2 bret favre
3 brett favre
4 brett favre
5 brett favre
6 brett favre
7 brett favre
8 brett favre
9 brett favre
10 brett favre
>> SSG Posted Here
     File :-(, x)
>>299062
>>299175
>1. Randy Moss
>> Anonymous
1. Clint Stoerner
2. Chad Hutchinson
3. Drew Henson
>> Anonymous
1. Romo
2. Romo
3. Romo
>> Anonymous
1. Matt Hasselbeck
2. Matt Hasselbeck
3. Colt Brennan
>> Anonymous
1. Steve Young/Joe Montana
2. Gino Torretta
3. Ryan Leaf
>> Anonymous
>>299294
I met Clint Stoerner; he's a nice guy. I'll make him my #1, too.
>> Anonymous
1. Peyton Manning
2. Dan Marino
3. Johnny Unitas
>> Raider Nation
     File :-(, x)
1. Rich Gannon
2. Rich Gannon
3. Rich Gannon

on a serious note
1. Joe Montana
2. Johhny Unitas
3. Jim Plunkette
>> Anonymous
Otto Graham
Joe Montana
Fran Tarkenton
>> Anonymous
     File :-(, x)
> Tony Romo
>> Anonymous
1. Brett Favre
2. Joe Montana
3. Brett Favre
>> Anonymous
1.Joe Montana
2.Johnny Unitas
3.Nolan Ryan
>> Anonymous
1. Marino
2. Elway
3. Favre

The best list
>> Anonymous
Favre
Favre
Favre
>> Anonymous
Tom Brady
Tom Brady
Tom Brady
>> Anonymous
brady because of his stunning good looks
>> Anonymous
Some high quality lists here.

1. Joe Montana
2. Peyton Manning
3. Michael Vick

Not a troll list, I love mobile QB's too much to have a list of 3 pocket faggots :(
>> Anonymous
>>299454
>kitna because of his stunning good looks

lolol amirite?
>> Anonymous
>>299461
You don't honestly believe your third pick, right? At least pick a good mobile QB like Steve Young or Fran Tarkenton or Randall Cunningham.
>> Anonymous
Stabler
Stabler
Stabler
>> Anonymous
>>299470

I'm a niners fan, and didn't want to be called a homer faggot for having Montana AND Young on my list.

But yes, 10 points for you. :(
>> Anonymous
>>299473
don't be shy, we all agree they were both great quarterbacks.
>> Anonymous
1. Montana
2. Unitas
3. Elway
>> Anonymous
>>299482
Montana and Young sucked they were system quarterbacks.
>> Anonymous
Brady is TOP 5.
>> Anonymous
1. Mark Brunell
2. Byron Leftwich
3. David Garrard/Steve Beurlein/Quinn Gray/Rob Johnson/Steve Matthews/Jamie Martin/Jonathan Quinn/Jay Fiedler/Matt Jones
>> Anonymous
>>299510
Yep...a system that went 5-0 in Super Bowls, Buddy! BWAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!
>> Anonymous
I'll one up you faggots. Here's my top 10.

1. Joe Montana
2. Johnny Unitas
3. Dan Marino
4. Brett Favre
5. John Elway
6. Fran Tarkenton
7. Steve Young
8. Roger Staubach
9. Otto Graham
10. Sammy Baugh
>> Anonymous
>>299553
Reverse 4 and 5 for many obvious reasons and I'll agree.
>> Anonymous
Bottom 3 Time:

1. Ryan Leaf
2. Alex Smith
3. Trent Dilfer
>> Anonymous
>>299565
Where is Couch?
>> Anonymous
#5, after Rax
>> Anonymous
>>299569

Yeah Couch is WAY worse then Dilfer. At least Dilfer had the substance to win a Super Bowl.
>> Anonymous
>>299540
Would've won more with Elway or Marino at quarterback.
>> Anonymous
I could have QB'd that super bowl team.

Jamal Lewis, Ray Lewis, the greatest secondary in the history of football... I can hand off to a 9001-carries/game back all day, too.
>> Anonymous
>>299583

Dilfer is like the Brad Johnsons and Don Majkowskis we've seen before. Average QBs who won't really be remembered. To consider him one of the worst of all time is stupid, there has been mare QBs far worse than him.
>> Anonymous
>>299577

SUPER BOWL RECORDS

Elway: 2-3
Marino: 0-1

Really? Or are you just trolling?
>> Anonymous
     File :-(, x)
Jim Kelly, Jim Kelly, and Jim Kelly.
>> Anonymous
>>299583
>the greatest secondary in the history of football.
I didn't know they had Lester Hayes and Mike Haynes at corner.
>> Anonymous
>>299596
Marino and Elway had no business being to the Super Bowls they were in (aside from Elway's last 2. Terrell Davis is a beast.). They played with shitty teams and STILL managed to win.
>> Anonymous
>>299609

But the 49ers still won fucking 5 without them.
>> Anonymous
>>299596
They didn't get to play on those San Francisco teams with players like Jerry Rice, Roger Craig, Ronnie Lott, etc. I bet those San Francisco teams have a lot more hall of famers than the Denver and Miami teams Elway and Marino played on.
>> Anonymous
>>299609
>>299617

Good point, but I still think that the 49ers were just fine with Montana/Young.

Actually, switch out Young in the 90s and the Niners would have probably won at least 3 with Marino or Elway at the helm.
>> Anonymous
>>299616
Trent Dilfer has won more superbowls than Dan Marino. Would you say Dilfer is a better quarterback than Marino?
>> Anonymous
>>299616
Exactly. The 49ers won those superbowls.

That has little to do with how good a quarterback is. Fucking Trent Dilfer has a Superbowl victory, yet he's not better than Marino who has none. You're an idiot.
>> scappy mcscrappertown
     File :-(, x)
1. Joe Montana
2. Kurt Warner.
3. Brian Sipe... HAH lol, obviously VINCENT FERRAGAMO
>> Anonymous
>>299623
>>299624
Dilfer/Marino Hivemind
>> Anonymous
>>299619
>still think that the 49ers were just fine with Montana/Young.
Of course they were, they were good quarterbacks.
>> Anonymous
>>299623
>>299624

I'm not arguing that at all. I'm just saying, I think the 49ers would have won just as many Super Bowl titles if they had Marino or Elway at the helm.
>> Anonymous
1. Jeff Hostetler
2. Jeff George
3. Vince Evans
>> Anonymous
>>299617
Denver has been absolutely fucked in Hall of Fame voting.
>> Anonymous
>>299641

1. Jeff George
2. Rich Gannon
3. Doug Williams
>> scappy mcscrappertown
>>299635
> I'm not arguing that at all. I'm just saying, I think the 49ers would have won just as many Super Bowl titles if they had Vince Ferragamo at the helm.

FIX'd.
>> Anonymous
>>299648
1. Jeff George
2. Jeff George
3. Jeff George
>> Anonymous
FOR THE VIKINGS

1. Fran Tarkenton
2. Randall Cunningham
3. Tommy Kramer
>> Anonymous
WARREN MOON
RANDAL CUNNINGHAM
RICH GANNON

THE BEST
>> Anonymous
>>299652
>FOR THE VIKINGS

1. Daunte Culpepper
2. Daunte Culpepper
3. Daunte Culpepper
>> Anonymous
1. Marino
2. Unitas
3. Montana
>> Anonymous
1. Kordell Stewart
2. Joseph Montana
3. Joseph Namath
>> Anonymous
>>299101
>But he isn't as good as Manning, and would not be capable of leading shitty teams to wins like other great QB's.
Lolwut? The Pats' 2004 Superbowl team was all no-names except for maybe Ty Law.

Manning has had All-Stars around him his entire career (Harrison, Wayne). Brady NOW has the All-Stars Manning has always had (Moss, Welker)
>> Anonymous
>>299678
Also:
1. Joe Montana
2. Johnny Unitas
3. Dan Marino
>> Anonymous
     File :-(, x)
TY LAWL UP IN THIS MOTHERFUCKER
>> Anonymous
1. John Elway
2. Bart Starr
3. Dan Marino.
..then
BRETT FAVRE BRETT FAVRE BRETT FAVRE BRETT FAVRE BRETT FAVRE BRETT FAVRE BRETT FAVRE BRETT FAVRE BRETT FAVRE
>> Anonymous
>>299678
Richard Seymour, Rodney Harrison, Willie Mcginist, etc. are not no-names.
>> Anonymous
     File :-(, x)
1. Steve Young
2. Jeff Garcia
3. Elvis Grbac
>> Anonymous
>>299689
My bad, I meant the '01 SB
>> Anonymous
1. Brett Favre
2. Bart Starr
3. Aaron Rodgers
>> Anonymous
>>299717
Packersfag much?
>> Anonymous
1) Elway - 3 superbowls in 4 years with no supporting cast, may have lost them, but when he did get help he got 2 rings.

2) Montana - Loads of talent around him, but still had the finest touch Ive ever seen, deadly accurate.

3) Favre - I'd love to put Marino here, but give the devil his due, he took over the records from him.
>> Anonymous
>>299718
Better believe it
>> Anonymous
in no particular order:

montana, marino, elway, unitas, kelly, young, favre, starr, moon, peyton, baugh, tarkenton, cunningham, staubach, bradshaw
>> Anonymous
>>299678All-Stars
> Welker

i lol'd
>> Anonymous
>>299736
Fucking Jim Kelly, man.

4 straight super bowls. Awesome.
>> Anonymous
>>299749

true, amazing feat to go to 4 superbowls straight
but..losing all 4? wtf?
>> Anonymous
1. Randall Cunningham
2. VC
3. Bubby Brister

the only accurate list in the whole damn thread
>> SSG Posted Here
>>299759
>2. /vc/

Was I the only one who thought that?
>> Anonymous
     File :-(, x)
i lol'd
>> Anonymous
Anyone who doesn't have Unitas or Montana in their top 3 is a fucking tool.
>> Anonymous
>>299948
wouldnt putting the best known QBs on their list make them a tool?
>> Anonymous
>>299950

Touche.

But seeing people actually rank Favre or Brady in a top 3 makes me rage.