Hall of Fame or not?
He's a Yankee, so of course.Yankees get all kinds of guys in the HOF who don't deserve it.
no
hall of fame or not i'm glad he finally got his 20 wins
not
>>368331Explain yourself
>>368342babe ruthfuck that guy whys he in the HOFwhat about joe demaggio fuck that guy too man
This thread is nothing but a gigantic troll magnet.
On the outside chance he gets 300 wins, sure.If not, I don't think so.
>>368354every yankee thread is a troll magnet they just love to hate
>>368327Survey says
>>368362Everything Yankee is a troll magnet IRL or on the internet.
>>368362Seriously. Is it that hard to ask for a civilized Yankee discussion without some fag bag coming in trying troll?>>368385Yeah but atleast in RL when you own someone who just runs their mouth about they dont say "OMG I just trolled you so hard." Its pretty lame.
*cough*Scooterisoverrated*cough*
Keep in mind, he is 100 wins over .500
>>368417Better than Schilling
In this era i don't think many will get to the hall of fame but more than likely moose will get in he is 100 wins over .500 and anyone with that record has made it to HOF so far
If he has 2 more solid years then I say he gets in, but it won't be on his first ballot.Moose was never really a dominate pitcher which is what the writers primarily look for. But longevity and consistency is a nice counter for that.
Also, he's pitched his entire career in the AL East, against champion teams like the Toronto Blue Jays, and the Yankees. He also pitched during the steroid era.
>>368445Dot.Since Moose got 20 wins this season. Maybe a no-hitter next year? Its wishful thinking.
He's had like 5 games where he almost pitched a Perfect Game, missed by one batter.
Yeah. He got stuck by Mr Almost Syndrome.