File :-(, x, )
Pick your player Anonymous
/sp/, whose better all-time?
>> MIGHTY MIGHTY BOSTON !3GqYIJ3Obs
Jason Baye.jpg
>> Anonymous
     File :-(, x)
>> Black ? Star !x8ngkAZjXE
which ever one plays better during playoffs
>> Anonymous
That would be Manny and his all time leading home runs in the post season.
>> Anonymous
Manny. No doubt. Manny has the two rings and playoff dominance. A-Rod has only playoff failures.
>> Anonymous
Just going purely by number of rings on fingers, Manny is infinitely better than A-Rod all time.
>> Anonymous
Manny's just..cooler.
>> Anonymous
arod will have the records, manny will have the bling.
>> Anonymous
A-Rod was our best shortstop of our time but moved to 3rd base to accommodate Jeter. What he should have done is forced Jeter to move to 2nd or center field, and stay at SS. A-Rod was a fantastic SS, and only an above average 3rd baseman. The funny thing is that the rumored A-Rod to Red Sox deal was for Manny. You wouldn't be able to do that deal today.
>> Anonymous
arod is kind of - well - a rod
>> Anonymous
Manny is cool and awesome and doesn't give a shit
A-Rod is a homo who chokes in the playoffs
>> Anonymous
>>388974
imho arod is a better individual player. manny is a better team player. simple as that.
>>389284
i totally concur with your comments but imagine if arod had been traded to the red sox, he would've put up some godly numbers at fenway. no one would be talking about when he will break the home run record but how many would he hit.
>> St.Feraligatr !VJOf9vVc0E
>>388974
A-Rod. His career playoff numbers aren't that bad when you look at them. People just hone in on his performance when he as a bad one and tend to over-look it when he plays well.
>> Anonymous
>>389290
...and unfortunately he'll prolly go down as the greatest player EVEN THOUGH HE KINDA SUCKS ASS.

I'm glad he plays well when you give him 130 million cause he certainly didn't do shit for the rangers.
>> Anonymous
fail-rod is better stats wise but manny is so0o fuckin clutch
>> Anonymous
Yankeesfag, I'd rather have Manny
>> Anonymous
man-ram is clearly better to all of those who have lived during his career. here's the thing baseball writers and fans are all big nerds and they need them both to die before they figure the relevance of either. An Rod will prolly have a longer career, break the HR record. Be an Yankee. But be the new Ernie Banks (i.e. awesome player sans rings). Dude, all we have to share with posterity is fucking MANRAM made the godamn Dodgers good. He even spotted them 8 consecutive losses, and still punked my Dbacks in that race for mediocrity. Swept Cubs single-handedly. (When did a rod beat anyones in poast-season?) One will end up with rings, a shaky reputation, and awesome stats. The other will end up with prolly the best stats EVAR, but no post-season success, frosted tips, also, frosted butts. But there will be a guy with a bow tie, Probably George Will's kid, swearing up and down the a rod was better than bonds and ruth combined.

tl:dr. Manram awesome.
>> Anonymous
>>390054
It's just Manny being Manny.