File :-(, x, )
Anonymous
HEY /fit/, who do you think would hurt more to get punched by?

A body builder, or a swimmer?

pic not really related.
>> Anonymous
what if the body builder used to box and the swimmer was secretly misa campo?
>> Anonymous
>>429061
just think of the most generic fucking body builder you can, and the most generic swimmer ever. Who's more likely to punch your head off?
>> Anonymous
>>429064
okay but the swimmer i am thinking of is a naked woman and the bodybuilder i am thinking of is also a naked woman and they're fucking

jerking off so hard righ now
>> Anonymous
     File :-(, x)
bodybuilders are still strong, they owuld just grab you and throw you around if u hit hijydtgndgndf
>> Anonymous
Chances are the bodybuilder is stronger and has more mass but a slower punch. Still I think he'd punch your head off easier than a swimmer would. Swimmers usually have strong back and shoulder muscles, but not much in the front.
>> Anonymous
Are we talking real body builders, or curl monkey gym rats? A real bodybuilder will punch your head off, swimmer not so much.
>> Anonymous
>>429080
I don't really know what you mean by curl monkeys, but when I think body builder I think like arnold swartzenegger before he got into movies.
>> Anonymous
>>429077
F = ma

The speed of the punch is just as important
>> Anonymous
>>429094
BUT WHAT ABOUT DA INERTIAAAAAA

Doesn't getting hit by something that's really heavy hurt more than something that weighs a lot less but is faster?
>> Anonymous
actualy punches are more like impusles so its m?v
so if we take it that both swimer and bodybuilder have zero knoledge how to make a punch and just punch straight thru target face thus giving the target equal % of impusle and since we took generic bodybuilder so his muscles is stil not affected that much by Hypertonus (sorry for using that word /fit/ but its the best analog in english that i came up) he will probably threw a better punch that swimer since swimer will lack the mass and wont really be much better at speed. but if we take a bodybuilder like Arnold then swimer will be stronger. and if they would've took any martial classes then shit would've changed dramaticaly
>> Anonymous
>>429057

Chances are if the swimmer is nick darcy the swimmer is gone hurt more. That kid mashed up a guys face pretty badly.
>> Anonymous
PROTIP= Just about any punch will hurt depending on exactly where they hit you, and how you react as the punch comes. If you just sit there watching it, it's gonna hurt, if you are moving towards it, lights out.
>> Anonymous
>>429094

F = 1/2*m*v^2
you're better of with speed
>> Anonymous
>>429109
you know ?v=a, right? you just gave the formula for force, not impulse

impulse = int(m?v(t),t)
>> Anonymous
Depends on the bodybuilder's range of motion. You can be huge, but if you can't move that fast or use motion to gather momentum, your punches will be seriously lacking.

Just remember, you can get hit by 2000 lbs moving at 1/2 a mile per hour and be fine, but 1/2 a pound moving at 1000 mph and it's all over.

Punches rely on the momentum transferred above anything else, so an ideal mix of speed and weight behind the punch would be best.
>> Anonymous
>>429379
dunno how its in your monkey college but in the rest of the world
?v=v1-v0
>> Anonymous
>>429266

That's kinetic energy, not force.
>> Anonymous
>>429477
i dunno how your faggoty junior high physics teacher taught you, but delta v is the fucking definition of acceleration

v = x + at
derive by t and you get
delta v = a
OH FUCKING HOLY SHIT

ps FAGGOT
v0-vf is only the definition of delta v WHEN WE'RE TALKING ABOUT UNIGODDAMNFORM ACCELERATION
>> Anonymous
>>429477
also doesn't change that he gave formula for force not impulse, which i also accurately provided
>> Anonymous
>>430260

>i dunno how your faggoty junior high physics teacher taught you, but delta v is the fucking definition of acceleration

Acceleration is delta V divided by T. I dunno how your faggoty Junior High Physics teacher taught you.
>> Anonymous
bodybuilder
>> Anonymous
>>430260
Oh god.

Let's look at your formula. Assume x is 0.

v = at

But according to you, v = a.

So a = at.

Hmmm.

Fuck, time doesn't exist!
>> Anonymous
>>430305
While we're at it, displacement is vt (assuming constant is 0).

But since v = at = a, t must be 1. So vt = v = a. So displacement is really a measure of acceleration.

From now on, my height is no longer 180cm, it is 180 m/s^2.
>> Anonymous
     File :-(, x)
>>430283
>>430305
People who actually took mechanics and know what the fuck they're talking about.

Well played, sirs.
>> Anonymous
>>430310

You mean 1.8 ms^2.

Remember your SI units, man.
>> Anonymous
>>430314

I meant m/s^2.

Fuck it, I'm going to bed.
>> Anonymous
>>430314
Well, it was just arbitrary conversions.
>> Anonymous
Average body builder would do more damage than the average swimmer. The swimmer probably wouldn't be trained in that motion to be significantly faster than the bodybuilder.
>> Anonymous
>>430305
no according to me DELTA v = a
>> Anonymous
Let me summarize this for you:
tl;dr comments, all full of brainiac-sort-of-wannabe-failure.

Bodybuilder.
1) a punch closely resembles a DB flat bench press with elbows tucked.
2) tricep has been trained to move weight quickly
3) nothing the swimmer has trained for carries over into a punching movement; not in terms of muscles nor nerves nor MRUs
4) back and "core" has been trained to transfer power from legs to arms via gravity-based movements

You can all BS about ROM and speed and blaaah, but I KNOWZ THSE SHILLZE.
>> Anonymous
>>430260
>>430283
>>430305
>>430310
wow, the retardation here is ovewhelming
just go to fucken wiki and search for impulse...
>> Anonymous
the swimer cuz what hurts on punches is pressure and if the swimmer has a smaller fist it will apply more pressure therefore more damage and pain, think like a knife what hurts more being stabbed or being hit by a flat board ?
>> Anonymous
Year round swimmer here. My punches suck ass. I'd say a body builder would hurt more.
>> Anonymous
>>430362

This.

/Thread
>> Anonymous
A bodybuilder may knock you out but a swimmer will make you gay.